ASTR380
9-29-09
Fossil Evidence for Evolution

Rock Types:

  • Igneous - solidified from molten material

  • Metamorphic - recrystallized by heat and/or pressure.

  • Sedimentary rock - rock composed of the transported remains of pre-existing rocks, i.e. sediment that has been deposited, compacted, and cemented by the precipitation of minerals from solution.

More


Stratigraphy: The interpretation of the sedimentary record

    Sediments are typically laid down in basins (oceans, seas, lakes, floodplains, etc) where they typically form laterally continuous layers. The physical relationships of these layers enable us to determine the relative sequence in which sediments were laid down, using the Principles of Stratigraphy. Some of these were suggested as early as 1027 by Ibn Sina (Avicenna), but were formally codified by Nicholas Steno (1638-1686) and James Hutton (1726-1797).

    • Original horizontality. Sediments originally deposited in horizontal layers. Therefore when horizontal and disturbed layers are found together, the horizontal ones must be younger, or else whatever disturbed the disturbed layers would have disturbed them, too.

    • Superposition. In undisturbed strata, older layers lie beneath younger ones because they must have already been present for the younger ones to be deposited on top of them.

    • Cross-cutting relations. If one structure cuts across another, then the one that is being cut must be oldest.

    Using these rules, it is possible to interpret the relative ages of any strata that can be seen in direct physical association.

More


Biotratigraphy:

    Of course, sedimentary rocks are deposited on the Earth's surface, in environments where Life lives. Consequently, fossils, the remains of living things, tend to be incorporated in them.

    In 1796 William Smith, a British civil engineer, added a fourth principle: Faunal succession, noting that different sedimentary rock units typically each contained distinct characteristic groups of fossil organisms - biostratigraphic fingerprints. Smith used these associations to construct the first technically competent geologic map, showing the relative ages of rock units distributed over a broad area. By this means it became possible to identify rocks of similar age even if they were on separate continents.

More


Absolute dating:

So fossils tell us something about the age of rocks, but what do rocks tell us about the age of fossils? Prior to the 20th century researchers really didn't have any idea of the numeric ages of the rocks they studied. That changed with the discovery of:

  • Radioactivity: The discovery that radioactive isotopes decayed into their stable daughter products with fixed probabilities that could be described by half-lives enabled geologists to determine absolute ages by comparing the concentrations of radioactive isotopes and their stable daughter products.

    Other lines of evidence later strengthened these results, so that the rock record provides multiple independent methods of establishing rock ages. These enable us to infer the chronology of the history of Life, as preverved in the rocks.

    More


    Fossils and Paleontology:

      Fossils: Are the record of past life incorporated into the rock record. Paleontology is the study of past life. We encounter fossils in sedimentary rocks because, unlike other rocks, sedimentary rocks form where life lives.

    • Definition: A fossil is any trace of an animal's body or behavior that becomes part of the rock record.

    • Two types of fossil:
    • Preservation: Despite what you have heard, organismal remains do not have to be altered in any way to be regarded as fossils. And yet, they often are altered. Major modes of preservation include:
      • No alteration: Materials preserved in rock record unchanged.
      • Permineralization: Pore space in material filled in with mineral cements. Common in porous material like wood or vertebrate bone.
      • Replacement: Original components have been dissolved and replaced by precipitates.
      • Carbonization: Soft tissues compressed into two dimension as carbon film
      • Molds and casts: Original material dissolved away but not replaced, leaving a mold or void that may be infilled with newer sediment later forming a cast.

    More


    Biases and Filters: Obviously, the fossils preserved in a rock will be different depending on the time at which the sediments in which they were preserved were laid down. This is not the only bias of the fossil record, however. A few other significant biases:

    More


    The History of Life in Five Minutes:

    What do the fossils tell us? A thumbnail chronology of life:

    • 4.56 g.a.: Earth accretes from planetesimals.

    • 3.8 g.a.: Earliest evidence of flowing surface water.

    • 3.7 g.a.: Earliest chemical evidence of life.

    • 3.4 g.a.: Earliest bacterium-grade fossils.

    • 3.0 g.a.: Earliest evidence of photosynthesis.

    • 2.7 g.a.: Earliest chemical evidence of eukaryotes - organisms with complex cells.

    • 830 - 600 Ma: Snowball earth episode - a series of drastic ice ages (the most severe on record). Although controversial, some evidence indicates glacial and oceanic pack ice at the equator. This seems to have exerted a strong selective pressure, because soon afterward, we witness the independent derivation of multicellularity in:
      • Animals
      • "Green algae" (including land plants)
      • Fungi
      • Red Algae
      • Brown Algae

    • 521 Ma: The Cambrian Explosion Historically, the first appearance of macroscopic shelly fossils. Enigmatic because many lineages learned the trick of secreting hard skeletons at roughly the same time. Could be due to the rise of predators. Many groups of organisms enter the fossil record. (See illustration at right.) Note: the Cambrian "explosion" may have had a very long "fuse."

    • 444 - 359 Ma: Fungi, plants, animals invade the land.

    • 251 Ma: Permo-Triassic extinction event. Planet Earth comes close to being sterilized.

    • 160-130 Ma: Origin of mammals, lizards, birds.

    • 64.5 Ma: Extinction of non-avian dinosaurs. Mammals, birds, crocodilians compete to be the dominant land animals.

    • ~50 Ma: Whales invade oceans.

    • ~7 Ma: Human and chimpanzee lineages diverge.

    More


    Compelling case studies:

    Birds:

    Archaeopteryx - "The first 'bird'" (Late Jurassic - ~150 Ma.)

    When first discovered, in the 1860s, this creature was the only known feathered fossil. Thus, for over a century it has been a fundamental benchmark in paleontology - "the first bird." When it was first described, it was separated from other fossil creatures by a huge gulf. In the last 40 years, as more specimens of Archaeopteryx have been found and studied, and as our knowledge of small theropod (meat-eating bipedal) dinosaurs has improved, Archaeopteryx has come to seem less and less unique, as:

    • The many features it shares with other bipedal dinosaurs (theropods) have come to light
    • A wide range of similar feathered, arm-flapping theropods has become known.
    Indeed, we can call it a bird, but if we were to see a living one, it would seem immediately weird with its:

    Thanks to the exceptional preservation conditions of rock units like the Yixian Formation of Liaoning Province, China, we now know that feather-like fuzz and proper feathers were widely distributed among smaller members of the theropods (the meat eating dinosaurs) like Caudipteryx.

    Indeed, we now know several small theropods that broadly resemble Archaeopteryx. Together, they form the base of the group Eumaniraptora, the theropods among whom feathers became functionally coupled with aerodynamics.

    Basal members of the major eumaniraptoran groups were broadly similar:

    • Deinonychosauria (including "Raptors", Middle Jurassic - Latest Cretaceous): Microraptor (reconstruction). From such beginnings, deinonychosaurs, evolved into larger terrestrial predators like Velociraptor.
    • Avialae (including birds, Early Cretaceous - Recent): Jeholornis (Skeletal reconstruction) - a chicken - turkey sized omnivore found with both seeds and fish in its gut.

    The Berlin Archaeopteryx 1881, from Linda Hall Library of Science, Engineering, and Technology

    More


    But could any of them fly? Their forelimb mechanics make this much clear: They could definitely flap. Biomechanically, Archaeopteryx is considered to be at or near the threshold of flight. Its wings are very short, its breast-bone is not large enough to serve as the origin for powerful flight muscles, and its skeleton was not strengthened and fused in the manner of modern birds. If it could fly, it did so weakly and over short distances. So why did it waste metabolic energy growing and supporting big feathered forelimbs? Indeed, what did Caudipteryx do with its dinky "wings?"

    Traditionally, paleontologists have considered two hypotheses for the origin of bird flight:

    Wing assisted incline running (WAIR):
    In the early 2000s research by Ken Dial of the University of Montana's Flight Laboratory revealed a locomotory behavior in modern birds not previously realized. Birds (in this case chukar patridges) were discovered to run vertically up surfaces, aided by flapping their wings back and forth in order to generate traction against the surface. They called this behavior Wing Assisted Incline Running, or WAIR for short.

    Note that these birds are NOT climbing in the typical sense: they are literally running up the sides of trees. Dial and his team studied the ontogenetic (growth) changes in the ability for birds to use this behavior, determining that WAIR is useful even in individuals with little dinky wings useless for flight. Sound familiar? We finally have a compelling evolutionary scenario for the evolution of wings from small theropod forelimbs.

    Just this year, Denver Fowler of the Museum of the Rockies added a complimentary hypothesis, that flapping was used in flightless predatory eunamiraptorans like Velociraptor in order to stabilize the body on top of struggling prey, like modern birds of prey do.

    Oddly, of the two major Eunamiraptoran groups, only Avialae stepped across the threshold of proper flight while deinonychosaurs backed away from it to become large flightless predators.

    More


    A rogue's-gallery of Cretaceous avialians

    Enantiornithes (Early - Latest Cretaceous): The most diverse and abundant group of birds of their time. Most were toothed. Encompassing a wide range of ecologies and sizes.
    Enantiornis from Pavel Riha

    More


    Ichthyornis (Late Cretaceous): A sea "bird" ecologically similar to living sea birds. This creature shared with proper birds, a keeled breast-bone to support more powerful wing muscles.

    Even so, it retained primitive features such as teeth


    Ichthyornis

    More


    AVES (Late Cretaceous - Recent): The last common ancestor of all living birds and all of its descendants. Distinguished by:
    • Toothless beaks
    For truly enigmatic reasons, these were the only theropods to escape the Cretaceous-Tertiary extinction.


    Prespyornis from Critters Pixel Shack

    More


    Whales

    Derived features of living whales:

    These are remarkable adaptations, but all the more so when one considers the starting point for this evolutionary trend: a primitive even-toed ungulate. Today, we think of these creatures as swift herbivores, but during the early Cenozoic Era (age of mammals), artiodactyls experimented with a variety of life styles including:

    More


    Competing hypotheses of evolutionary history: