GEOL 102 Historical Geology
Spring Semester 2008
The Proterozoic Eon III: Snowball Earth and the Garden of Ediacara
The Neoproterozoic Era has recently been divided into three Periods: Tonian ("stretching",
after continued expansion of the platform covers": 1000 - 850 Ma),
Cryogenian ("ice origins", after the Snowball Earth glaciations: 850 - 630 Ma), and
Ediacaran (After Ediacara Springs, Australia: 630 - 542 Ma). The boundaries of the
Tonian are arbitrarily defined, while the uppermost boundary of the Cryogenian is the the
end of the Marinoan glaciation (and hence may be shifted to about 635.5 Ma pending further
revisions), and the uppermost boundary of the Ediacaran is the
first appearance of the trace fossil Trichophycus pedum (and thus the oldest
biostratigraphically-determined boundary).
Climates of the Proterozoic
Good evidence of rising levels of oxygen in atmosphere (and hence oceans):
- BIFs may require extremely low levels of oxygen, but clearly cannot form at higher
levels: their presence in Archean and early Paleoproterozoic and almost total absence
after 2.0 Ga suggests that levels had risen too high by 2.0 Ga
- Uranite and pyrite are unstable at surface temperatures and pressures in presence of
atmospheric oxygen; disappear by 2.3 Ga
- Red beds require oxygen to form: do not appear until 2.0-1.8 Ga
- Stromatolites (and thus potential oxygenators of atmosphere) common throughout
Proterozoic
Suggests atmosphere of about 1% of atmosphere was oxygen at end of Archean, rising to
10% (or half of modern level) by end of Proterozoic.
During Paleoproterozoic, good evidence of widespread glaciation (tillites,
striations, carbon shifts).
During Neoproterozoic (in particular, from c. 750-580 Ma), evidence for superglaciations:
- Carbon isotope shifts far greater than seen during Phanerozoic glaciations
- Tillites, striations, etc. in paleoequatorial regions
Strong evidence for a Neoproterozoic Snowball Earth
- Break-up of Rodinia leaves many smaller continents near equator
- Climate change due to new weather patterns: lots of carbon dioxide sucked out of
atmosphere due to erosion
- Temperature drops due to reduced greenhouse, pack ice builds up on poles and
continental glaciers in mountains
- Positive feedback loop: ice increases albedo, drops temperature, ice spreads,
albedo increases, etc.
- Pole-to-equator-to-pole glaciation:
- Hydrologic cycle stops (and thus erosion stops)
- Ice thickens to 100s of m to 1 km, so photic zone forbidden to life; oceans become
anoxic (reappearance of BIFs)
- Life clings to refuges in ice cracks & along mid-ocean ridges
- Glaciers cannot build up after end of hydrologic cycle (no new snow!), and gradual
creep off of continents
- Glacial conditions persist until slow (10 Myr or so?) build up of carbon dioxide
due to volcanic activity to form a supergreenhouse (many MANY times modern levels)
- EXTREMELY fast melting, superhot world, massive rapid deposition of
carbonates, massive blooms of organisms
- Cycle seems to have happened at least three (possibly four or more times in Neoproterozoic: the Sturtian
(~720 Ma), Marinoan (~636 Ma), and Gaskiers (~580 Ma) are the best studied and established,
but there may be others.
The reason Neoproterozoic superglaciations stop and haven't been seen again may be due
to the rise of complex animals, which were able to liberate the carbon in the sediment
through bottom-feeding (previously was simply trapped in sediment).
Proterozoic Life:
Stromatolites still common, becoming even more common c. 2.2 Ga, becoming more complex
c. 1.2 Ga.
Oldest known eukaryotes (cells with nuclei and other complex organelles) at about
2.1 Ga, probably formed by endosymbiosis (prokaryote-grade organisms joining
together to form a more complex cell). Fossils from
Bitter Springs Formation of
Australia (1 Ga) looks as if they show cells dividing.
Oldest known acritarchs (cysts of some kind of fossil photosynthesizers, possibly
dinoflagellates) at c. 2 Ga; become complex around 600 Ma; the main index
fossils for the Proterozoic
Metabionts: multicellular organisms include:
- Rhodophyta (red algae, some make calcareous skeletons): may form a larger group Primoplantae with
the viridiplants and the unicellular glaucophytes
- Phaeophyta (brown algae or kelp; a multicellular group within Chromista, and thus relatives
of diatoms and coccolithophorids)
- Viridiplantae, or green algae and plants: basal forms are unicellular, but paraphyletic Charophyta
(one of the green algae) and Plantae or Embryophyta (true plants) are multicellular
- Fungi: together with animals and various unicellular groups form larger clade Opisthokonta
- Animalia: closest relatives are unicellular
choanoflagellates; animal
phylogenetic interrelationships are a matter of a LOT of study!
Some of these groups have records back to the Proterozoic:
- Possible rhodophytes from 1.25 Ga, but only clearly present from Cambrian
- Possible phaeophytes from Ediacaran Period but not particularly convincing: better
possible Ordovician forms, and oldest definite kelps not until Cenozoic
- Possible charophytes from Neoproterozoic, but not definite until Cambrian (true
plants do not show up until Ordovician)
- Fungi not clearly present until Ordovician: no strong argument for multicellular
fungi in Proterozoic (unless the vendobionts are lichens)
Animal record is somewhat better, but still much debate:
- Molecular data suggests many true animal lineages had diverged at around 1 Ga
- Some controversial trace fossils from c. 800 Ma: only animals (with muscles) can move
sediment around
- Definite animal-generated trace fossils by 570 Ma
- Phosphatized eggs and embryos of primitive animals in China from 600 Ma
- Tiny (1 mm or smaller) calcified shells:
- The Ediacaran fauna (from
Ediacara Hills, Australia, and
elsewhere from c. 570 Ma
onward)
The
Ediacaran fauna is preserved only as impressions in sediment. Indicate a variety of
organisms. Originally were pigeon-holed into modern groups, but new evidence suggests
that a number of types of animals are present:
- Early cnidarians
(members of the coral-sea anemone-jellyfish group), large polyps with their butts in the sand
- "Vendobionts"
- A unique (and extinct) radiation of multicellular forms with a quilt-like body
construction: see here and
here and
here.
- May have fed by chemosynthesis (there is no evidence for mouths or anus in these
creatures)
- Some up to 1 m or more across, but thinner than a slice of bread
- Kimberella: apparently an early mollusk or mollusk-relative; known from
impressions of its foot
and probable grazing marks
None of the Ediacaran fauna apparently burrowed into the sediment, nor had preservable
hard parts.
Interestingly, almost all the evidence for multicellular organisms comes
AFTER the Gaskiers Glaciation. Some speculate that selective pressures from
these hard times led to development of complex life; others that the appearance of
creatures able to mobilize the carbon in the sea sediments kept atmospheric carbon
dioxide from getting low enough to trigger the super ice ages.
To Next Lecture.
To Previous Lecture.
To Syllabus.
Last modified: 10 January 2008