GEOL 104 Dinosaurs: A Natural History

Fall Semester 2017
Taxonomy & Species

The systematic paleontology section of the initial description of the Late Jurassic heterodontosaurid Fruitadens (Butler et al. (2009) doi: 10.1098/rspb.2009.1494)

Key Points:
•Taxonomy (biological nomenclature) is a way of having a universal set of names for groups of living things.
•A formal set of rules exists for naming and organizing taxa (named groups of organisms). Among these are that taxa are named in Latin (or at least in Latinate style) and that they are organized as a nested hierarchy.
•Species represent a fundamental unit in taxonomy. Species are grouped into genera.
•There is no single universally recognized method of identifying when two individuals are in teh same species This is even more problematic for fossils, where some relevant information (such as interbreeding, DNA, and so on) is not available.
•Taxonomic differences are not the only reason that two individuals might be different: ontogenetic, sexual, geographic & individual variations have to be considered as well.

Taxon (pl. taxa): a named group of organisms.

Traditionally, each culture had its own name for the animals, plants, and other organisms in their region. But EACH culture had its own set of names, so the same type of animal might have many different names. During the 1600s and 1700s, methods were proposed for a formal scientific set of names.

Carlos Linnaeus developed a universal set of rules in the Systema Naturae ("System of Nature") in 1758; later workers added and modified the system (primarily with the addition of new "ranks").

Some of the Linnean rules:

Linnean taxonomy has its own special set of grammatical rules:

Because there is disagreement about the features used to define a particular species or genus, different biologists and paleontologists will sometimes disagree about which specimens belong in a particular species, and which species belong in a particular genus (and so forth).

For those interested in a website concerning some unusual Linnean species names, click here.

What is a species? Above we see the rules for these names, but it doesn't tell us about what it is being named.

Linnaeus' "species" were taxa like lions, tigers, black bears, etc. These were assemblages of individuals that share certain attributes:

Darwin did not regard species as a distinct "kind" of biological entity. Instead, he considered them as essentially the same thing as goegraphic or stratigraphic variations (see these below), but ones in which extinction has removed the intermediate forms that otherwise would blend into the closest living relative group.

20th Century biologist Ernst Mayr (and most contemporary biologists) formalized their definition of a species as a "naturally occurring populations that interbreed and produce viable fertile offspring".

But there are some problems with this. For one: hybrids (crosses between two separate species) do occur naturally, and many of these are actually fertile! And for paleontologists: we can't test interfertility between populations because they are dead!

So we are stuck looking only at shapes (and in fact, only the shapes of those hard parts that survive fossilization).

The question then becomes: how different do two individuals, or two populations, have to be for us to consider them different species? This is actually a terribly difficult question even with living organisms!! There are several sources of variation:

In fact, the recognition that species were NOT absolute kinds, but instead have "fuzzy" boundaries that blend into each other, is one of the main clues to the discovery of evolution.

To Next Lecture.
To Previous Lecture.
To Lecture Schedule.

Last modified: 26 June 2017

Diversity of horned ceratopsids (and related dinosaurs), by Julius Csotonyi